The Battle for AGOA: A Defining Moment in U.S.-Africa Relations

On December 10, 2025, the halls of Capitol Hill transformed into a powerful forum where the future of U.S.-Africa trade relations hung in the balance. The African Growth & Opportunity Act (AGOA) Alliance Initiative, in partnership with the Congressional Black Caucus, convened ambassadors from across the African continent, embassy representatives, political leaders, and key stakeholders, including Dr. Melvin Foote, for a series of critical dialogues that would determine whether America would honor its 25 year commitment to African economic partnership or retreat into isolationism at the moment Africa needs strategic allies most. The House Ways and Means Committee, under Chairman Jason Smith’s leadership, advanced H.R. 6500, a proposal to extend the African Growth and Opportunity Act for three years until December 31, 2028. Yet the atmosphere in the room reflected deep uncertainty. While the proposed extension represents progress from the Trump administration’s initial endorsement of merely a one-year extension, it falls dramatically short of what African nations and American businesses desperately need: a 15-year commitment that AGOA Alliance members advocate for to provide genuine stability for long-term investment and economic planning.

Congresswoman Gwen Moore addressed the committee with measured concern, acknowledging AGOA’s importance while noting the limitations of the current proposal. The reality conveyed by representatives familiar with the House committee’s thinking was sobering; under the current administration’s hostile posture toward Africa, achieving the substantive multi-decade extension that economic logic demands appears increasingly unlikely. The African Growth and Opportunity Act emerged in 2000 from the visionary work of Congressman Charles Rangel, working alongside Rosa Whitaker, who then served as Senior Trade Advisor to Rangel and helped craft legislation that would fundamentally reshape America’s economic engagement with the African continent. Whitaker, who went on to become America’s first Assistant U.S. Trade Representative for Africa, understood what many policymakers still fail to grasp that Africa represents a source of critical minerals, resources, and an investment in human capital that will define the 21st century global economy. By 2050, Africa will comprise 30% of the world’s population, making it the fastest growing demographic force on the planet. This is beyond accessing cobalt, lithium, or rare earth elements, though those matter profoundly for American technology and defense industries. This is about recognizing that Africa’s billion-plus young, entrepreneurial, and increasingly educated citizens represent the largest emerging consumer market and workforce in human history.

Consider the real-world impact on American entrepreneurs like Skip Richmond, whose business model depends on importing apparel from Ghana. Under AGOA’s duty-free provisions, Richmond could build a competitive, profitable enterprise that created jobs both in Ghana and in the United States. But without AGOA’s protections, he faces tariffs exceeding 30%, making his business model unsustainable and handing market dominance to Chinese competitors who face no such barriers in their African trade relationships.

This is the crux of America’s strategic miscalculation in trade policy. While Washington debates and delays, China has systematically built comprehensive trade relationships across the African continent, investing in infrastructure, manufacturing partnerships, and long-term economic integration. AGOA should not be identified as foreign aid but rather as a strategic economic policy that protects over 1.3 million African jobs and hundreds of thousands of American jobs while generating virtually no cost to U.S. taxpayers.

Since 2000, AGOA has tripled U.S. exports to sub-Saharan Africa from $5.9 billion to over $18 billion, while delivering more than $500 billion in duty-free African exports to American consumers and businesses.

The December 10th gathering brought together a remarkable coalition. Rosa Whitaker, now co-chair of the AGOA Alliance, stood alongside several stakeholders launching the “Continue AGOA!” initiative that is a bipartisan effort backed by the African Export-Import Bank. Their message resonated with the dozens of African ambassadors and diplomatic leaders present. Dr. Rosa Whitaker reminded the assembly of her work with the late Jack Kemp in founding the original AGOA Coalition, a bipartisan achievement that once represented America at its best, recognizing mutual benefit over zero-sum competition. Congressman Richard Neal, ranking member of the Ways and Means Committee, has joined other Democratic leaders in calling AGOA’s expiration “unacceptable” and “disastrous,” emphasizing that it has “always been renewed on time and never lapsed” until now. African nations want to partner with the United States, but America must demonstrate it values these relationships as strategic priorities. Jonathan Jackson, son of Reverend Jesse Jackson and now a member of the House Foreign Affairs Subcommittee on Africa, delivered what attendees described as a powerful address connecting the historical struggles of the Civil Rights Movement to contemporary economic justice for African nations. Also present were Congressional Black Caucus members, including Delegate Stacey Plaskett, who have long championed African engagement as both a moral imperative and an economic necessity.

The uncomfortable truth that permeated the dialogue is the current administration’s rhetoric and policies toward Africa have been characterized by hostility that threatens decades of carefully built strategic partnerships. At a moment when geopolitical competition demands that America strengthen alliances across the Global South, policy decisions rooted in xenophobia rather than strategic analysis represent a profound self-inflicted wound. The ambassadors, diplomats, and embassy representatives who filled the room on December 10th sent an unambiguous message of wanting to work with the United States, but America must reciprocate with respect, consistency, and recognition of mutual benefit. Trade policy determines livelihoods, sustains jobs, and shapes the material conditions under which millions of workers and families on both sides of the Atlantic build their futures. In an interconnected global economy, America’s prosperity emerged through internationalization and engagement. The same logic that built American economic power in the 20th century applies with even greater force in the 21st century for strategic trade relationships create competitive advantages, open markets for American goods, secure critical supply chains, and build political goodwill that translates into security cooperation.

The Path Forward

As the AGOA Alliance mobilizes bipartisan support for the three-year extension currently before Congress, its members continue pressing for the 15-year commitment that genuine economic stability demands. This is due to the insight of knowing that businesses cannot make transformative investments based on political whims and short-term calculations. The question confronting American policymakers is,…

Will the United States embrace the strategic logic that visionaries like Charles Rangel, Rosa Whitaker, Gwen Moore, and generations of leaders cultivated of realizing that Africa’s rise represents American opportunity? Or will xenophobia and shortsighted political maneuvering sabotage our national interest at precisely the moment when China and other competitors are deepening their foothold across the continent? 

This is about trade policy and whether America possesses the wisdom and courage to invest in partnerships that will define global economic and political power for the next half-century. The December 10th gathering demonstrated that support for AGOA transcends partisan politics, uniting business leaders, civil society organizations, diplomatic representatives, and Congressional members around shared recognition of mutual benefit. Whether that coalition can overcome administrative hostility and legislative gridlock will determine not just the fate of a trade policy, but whether America remains a serious partner for Africa’s future or cedes that role entirely to competitors who recognize what is being sacrificed.

Complicating matters further, discussions have emerged around excluding South Africa from AGOA. This move would represent a catastrophic rupture in U.S.-Africa economic trade relations, with reverberations felt across the entire continent and within American industries. As one of Africa’s largest and most diversified economies, South Africa serves as the indispensable manufacturing, logistics, and financial hub anchoring regional value chains in automotive production, agriculture, and light manufacturing that extend across Southern Africa. Severing its AGOA benefits would immediately undercut South African competitiveness in U.S. markets, eliminate tens of thousands of jobs on both sides of the Atlantic, and fragment the integrated production networks linking factories and suppliers throughout the region. For the United States, such punitive action would accelerate South Africa’s inevitable pivot toward China and other competitors eager to deepen their strategic foothold, while demolishing America’s credibility as a reliable trade partner committed to mutual prosperity rather than weaponized commerce. At this critical juncture, when African nations are evaluating which global powers merit their trust and partnership, America’s choices will either demonstrate wisdom and foresight or confirm that we have abandoned strategic thinking for the costly indulgence of ideology divorced from national interest.

1. (https://amcham.co.za/news/usafrica-congress-announces-vote-agoa-renewal)

2. (https://allafrica.com/stories/202512090649.html)

3. (https://allafrica.com/stories/202512090555.html)

4. (https://www.quiverquant.com/news/Press+Release:+Congresswoman+Gwen+Moore+Addresses+AGOA+Extension+and+Trade+Policies)

5. (https://www.bhfs.com/insight/agoa-expiration-whats-next/)

6. (https://gwenmoore.house.gov/news/)

7. (https://neal.house.gov/2025/09/30/neal-sanchez-sewell-call-on-congress-to-reauthorize-agoa/)

8. (https://www.mynigeria.com/NigeriaHomePage/NewsArchive/A-towering-legacy-Honoring-congressman-Charles-Rangel-s-enduring-contributions-to-Africa-750441)

9. (https://responsiblestatecraft.org/agoa-africa-trump/)

10. (https://agoa.info/21-country/4054-ghana.html)

11. https://youtu.be/9RRnt7y7kno?si=qMevCRnEQR-w0_DX